Have Camera-phones made dedicated cameras Obsolete?
“The best camera to take a photo is the one you have with you. Otherwise you might miss the shot” – should be every photographers motto.
High-quality photos are the ideal, but as we discussed in our previous article,high-quality photography often can’t be done without bulky and expensive DSLR cameras, which you just won’t always have with you, when that perfect photo opportunity presents itself.
Sometimes you need something more convenient. So in this 2-part article, we asses whether a ‘Camera-phone’, a phone with a built-in camera can do the job? Or is the ‘middle-ground’ of the Point’n'Shoot camera the best compromise?
Well, with it established that both of these can’t generally use interchangeable lenses, and generally take much lower quality photographs than DSLRs (again, read our previous article comparing the higher-end DSLR cameras to the cheaper Point’n'Shoot Cameras if you need more information), lets assess the Pro’s and Con’s of these two ‘low-end’ photographic options:
We’re going to start by looking at the issues that don’t directly affect picture quality (the lens, sensor etc.), simply because these are easiest for the amateur to get their head round:
The Dedicated Point’n'Shoot Camera route, General Advantages:
1. For non-technical users; Simple Photo Backup & Safety:
Photo’s should regularly be copied to your computer. On a phone or camera, there is always a risk the phone/camera will be lost/stolen, and then the precious photos are gone also. When you get back from a trip, you are quite likely to specifically transfer the photos from your camera to your computer (where they are relatively safe). It’s an easy, and beneficial routine to get in to when you have a dedicated camera.
- Unlike photos sitting on your camera-phone, where there is no ‘mental trigger’ of ‘putting the camera away’ at the end of the trip. Those photos are more likely to stay on the camera-phone, and be at risk from theft/loss.
2. Flexible Storage:
Almost all Point’N'Shoot cameras store their photos on something like a ‘Storage Card’ that can be removed from the camera. Many camera-phones, the iPhone being a good example, can only store photo’s ‘in the phone’. Removable storage generally lets you store more photos than if you only had ‘on-board’ storage (like most camera-phones). It gives you a greater ‘capacity’. ‘Storage Cards’ allow the flexibility to classify one ‘card’ for only work use during the day, and in the evening you can swap the ‘cards’ and use another one for personal use. Or have one card for the photos of your French holiday, one for your Spanish holiday, etc. etc.
- Which you often can’t do with a camera-phone.
3. Sole-function devices work better:
A dedicated camera is just that. Dedicated It’s sole function, and design considertion, is to take the best pictures for your budget. A multi-purpose device like a Camera-Phone? Well it’s full of compromises. It might ‘multi-task’ (badly) so it can be your music-player at the same time (giving slow focusing pictures), it’s buttons might be placed for ideal Phone-use, but not camera-use. And the more complex the unit, the more can go wrong. Sole-function devices, carry-out that function…better.
4. Cost: 2 devices is cheaper than one.
At this end of the market a dedicated camera will give slightly better pictures than the best camera-phone. And it will do so for around £40 less. It’s hard to make direct comparisons, but generally having both camera and phone in one, is more expensive.
5. Loss/Theft: Lose a camera-phone it will cost you more…
Loss and theft are unfortunate, but you can lessen the blow. Stress-saving companies like Gadget Cover can help with insurance for all these devices, but lets try and keep the costs as low as possible hey? If the cost of regular phone and decent Point’n'Shoot camera is less than an equivilent Camera-Phone, then losing your ‘device’ while taking photos will cost you less if you using a dedicated camera. It also means you’ll lose only the photos. And not the photos, phone contacts, past text messages etc. etc. Of a camera-phone. Though Gadget-cover do offer that handy free 3Gb data-backup on their (Camera-)Phone policies.
The Camera-Phone by itself route, General Advantages:
1. For technical users; Easy Copying of Photos to the Internet:
For the technically savvy among us, Camera-Phones have offer the ultimate method of keeping your photos safe from loss, and the quickest method of publishing them to social websites like Flickr and Facebook – which youngsters are finding increasingly useful. Camera-phones generally have WiFi & Mobile Phone internet built in, Point’n'Shoot Cameras generally don’t.
- This means photos can be backed-up to ‘the net’ as soon as they are taken. You don’t have to remember to do it later, and if you lose the device before you finish the trip and copy the photos to the computer, it’s not an issue, as the photos can be sitting safe on the Internet for you. And whatever your reasoning, if you want to publish the photos to the Internet, the camera-phones ability to publish ‘in-the-field’ from almost anywhere, beats most dedicated cameras hands-down.
2. Having a camera in your phone saves space by you having less gadgets :
Less bags, less gear, more space all round : And surprisingly, a phone with a camera in, is generally not significantly bulkier than a phone without. Even when an expandable lens is built-in! Isn’t miniaturisation wonderful!
3. If you always have your camera(-phone), you’ll never miss that shot!:
Yes you might get better quality photos/shots from a dedicated camera, but many photo opportunities happen briefly, spontaneously, and only once. With a camera-phone you’ll have the pleaseure of being able to record these moments. With a separate camera, you’ll generally miss them.
It’s better to have a low-quality photo, than no photo at all! And these photos are generally the most fun too!
In Summary:
Well despite the increased popularity of Camera-Phones, in part 1 of this article, the dedicated Point’n'Shoot Camera seems to have more going for it.
Though the value of each point will differ for individual photographers.
Can the Camera-phone swing things back it’s way? You’ll have to read the next Part of the article to find out!
Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »




